Add new comment

Q.  Do we have an ad that shows this watch at all? 

A.  No. 

So, no basis for calling it a Phantom at all.

In another thread last week you argued that the watch should be judged by the strap it has on it at the time of posting on this site.  In that case, you have a watch that does not match any known advertisement.

By the way, the Phantom "B" is a different watch and it has nothing to do with the strap.  I'll be posting an ad shortly.

It's your theory, I'm just following it to its natural conclusion.  You have no more basis for calling this watch a Phantom than a Phantom A, or anything else.  As you admitted, it's just a guess based on one non-matching ad. 

You should allow others the same right to choose the "A", or whatever, if that's the guess they are more comfortable with.  You are not the sole judge of what is a good guess and what is not.